Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:22 pm
#1719138
I don't think Shoreham had a choice about providing full ATC. As with Wycombe, I understand that the CAA mandate it.
Yes separation is your responsibility, but the ATCO can't give you unsafe instructions like telling you to join a circuit with more aircraft in than he can handle. The time taken to make the calls, the readbacks, time for landing aircraft to vacate etc means that there is a finite limit on the number of aircraft that can be handled in the circuit under ATC. If he can't fit you in, he won't let you in. Under A/G no-one can stop you joining and the only thing stopping you joining 11 other aircraft into the circuit is your own sense of self preservation.
I don't think Shoreham are trying to achieve anything in particular. It's not like they need more weekend visitors.
Yes separation is your responsibility, but the ATCO can't give you unsafe instructions like telling you to join a circuit with more aircraft in than he can handle. The time taken to make the calls, the readbacks, time for landing aircraft to vacate etc means that there is a finite limit on the number of aircraft that can be handled in the circuit under ATC. If he can't fit you in, he won't let you in. Under A/G no-one can stop you joining and the only thing stopping you joining 11 other aircraft into the circuit is your own sense of self preservation.
I don't think Shoreham are trying to achieve anything in particular. It's not like they need more weekend visitors.
Schrödinger's cat walks into a bar. And doesn't.