Page 2 of 5

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 6:55 pm
by Charliesixtysix
It sounds like there is no AVGAS in the offing at Oban yet, so a cynic might suggest this is another clever bit of timing by the UAV service provider to demonstrate no adverse effect of GA prior to commercial rollout.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 7:42 pm
by Iceman
I wouldn’t imagine that there’s any connection between the current AVGAS unavailability at Oban and this operation whatsoever. GA fixed-wing aircraft could only land at Glenforsa whereas these drones can land pretty well anywhere.

Iceman 8)

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 8:31 pm
by Charliesixtysix
Agreed. No connection, other than that there is unlikely to be much ga activity next spring if there is no fuel up there?

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 8:40 pm
by austerity
I have been told that these drones cannot operate in IMC, darkness or rain. The West Of Scotland does not appear to be a suitable location to attempt to provide a vital service in this manner rather than using the BN Islander at Oban.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 8:51 pm
by Iceman
@Charliesixtysix, the last that I heard on the Oban fuel front was that the tank had been bought, the foundations were in and that a self-service pump would be introduced. I know that there’s not much incentive for them at the moment but you’d have thought that they’d have used the down time to get on with the project. Too much to ask, rather unsurprisingly :roll:.

Iceman 8)

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 9:03 pm
by Miscellaneous
@Charliesixtysix, @Iceman when I spoke to Oban in August when sorting out my Coll OOH permit I was told the expectation was for the work, which had been held up by covid, was due to be completed by Dec. So hopefully the infrastructure is at least there?

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 9:29 pm
by alexh
Charliesixtysix wrote:Agreed. No connection, other than that there is unlikely to be much ga activity next spring if there is no fuel up there?


Do bear in mind that there are two flying clubs at Oban, many of whose members are not dependent on local Avgas (although some of us are!) In good times there are also plenty of inbounds from other Scottish airfields who need not uplift fuel, so COVID and weather permitting there will be GA activity. :D

Iceman’s summary of the Avgas situation remains accurate, progress apparently delayed by COVID
Alex

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 10:19 pm
by Charliesixtysix
Excellent, the more flying ( and fliers likely to comment on the ACP) the better.

Your update on the fuel situation sadly agrees closely with the brief I received on this subject yesterday - and does not inspire confidence of improving Avgas availability for ( at least the early part of ) summer this year.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 10:55 pm
by riverrock
As an aside on fuel, Glasgow Flight Center have just completed installation of an AVGAS pump. They are still sorting out details but should be in regular use, including for visitors soon. https://glasgowflightcentre.com/ You can see landing and handling charges appear much more competitive than before. Apparently they are still working out if the £39 landing fee can include some parking. I'm not a member there - just saw their announcement.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Wed Jan 13, 2021 10:58 pm
by Iceman
I’ve flown over Glasgow but never in to the airport so the news of possibly more attractive fees could make this a viable alternative for fuel.

Iceman 8)

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Thu Jan 14, 2021 8:39 am
by CloudHound
Don’t forget Cumbernauld :thumleft:

They have self service fuel and recently increased capacity. There’s a very comfy hotel next door too.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Thu Jan 14, 2021 4:35 pm
by Rowans
A better place to do such a trial might be somewhere like Mallaig or Ullapool with similar remote medical practices.

But if has to be Oban based, they could use other locations such as Colonsay or Iona which would have much less impact of flying, particularly if below 400ft.

Indeed if it just to prove the concept / principal, presumably there is no reason why it has to involve remote medical practices, and any sot of location could be used.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Thu Jan 14, 2021 4:42 pm
by riverrock
If the trial was all in radio range of Oban, and Oban were able to provide a Danger Area Crossing Service, most of the issues would be mitigated. However Glenforsa isn't in radio range of Oban - my memory is you need to be airborne first - and I believe on the previous trial they just provided info on activation, not a crossing service.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Thu Jan 14, 2021 5:51 pm
by Cub
The reliance on radio contact or airspace segregation is exactly what we should be working to remove.

The generation of a recognised air environment via EC and the rebroadcast of that air picture to all users is the way forward IMHO.

Re: ACP for Drones over and around Oban / Glenforsa / Mull

PostPosted:Thu Jan 14, 2021 6:03 pm
by G-BLEW
Don't forget, Brendon Walsh from Glenforsa will be joining us for some of tonight's livestream, as will Cat Burton (to chat about the operation of Cardiff's airspace)

Ian